Dead Issue
I don't think it's a stretch to say that the person happiest by this news is none other than Stephen Harper.
posted by calgarygrit at 1:52 p.m.
Canadian Politics, Canadian Politics and more Canadian Politics. From the mind of a Calgary Liberal, now living in the centre of the universe.
Online Poker in Canada
Calgary Musicals
Blog Roll
A BCer in Toronto
Adam Radwanski
Big City Liberal
Calgary Liberal
Coyne
Daveberta
Delacourt
Far and Wide
538
Impolitical
James Bow
Kady O'Malley
Pundit's Guide
Scott's DiaTribes
Silver Powers
Stephen Taylor
Warren
Wells
Liblogs
Progressive Bloggers
Blogging Dippers
Blogging Tories
News
Bourque
Calgary Herald Blogs
CBC
CTV
Full Pundit
Globe & Mail
The Hill Times
Canada.com
National Newswatch
Best of CalgaryGrit
ELXN41
Election '09 '08
(41% of) Alberta Votes 2008: The Ed Files Election
The Race for Stornoway (2006)
(65% of) Canada Votes 2006
2011
In support of a primary system
The Fall and Rise of Dalton McGuinty
ALP leadership candidate profiles
LPC leadership race expectations
Election Postmortems: Greens, Bloc, NDP, Lib, CPC
Alberta Politics FAQ
Swann Song
2010
Lessons from Nenshi Victory
What's the matter with Calgary?
Calgary mayoral candidate profiles
Tony Clement bungles the Census
Everything you wanted to know about the Census
In favour a Liberal-CPC merger
Against a Liberal-NDP merger
Moment of the Decade
2009
Christmas Letters: May, Layton, Ignatieff, Harper
Advice for Ignatieff
Wild Rose Leadership Race
Alberta Politics Gets Interesting
MP Interviews
Michael Ignatieff profile
One Member One Vote
2008
Alberta Liberal Leadership Race
The Race Victory March for Stornoway Sussex Stornoway
Political Insanity
Duelling Pro-Democracy Rallies
Coalition
Campaigning in New Hampshire
Rebuilding the Big Red Machine
Obama Endorsement
CG on Test the Nation
2007
2007 Year in Review Quiz
The Saga of Paul Jackson
The Saga of Craig Chandler
Dion's First Year
David Karwacki Interview
Peace in Our Time
Quebec Debat Live Blog
Green Questions Series
Harper's First Year
2006
2006 Year in Review Quiz
Dion Wins
CG Unmasked
Results for People
Gerard Kennedy Endorsement
Rebuilding the Liberals
Draft Paul Hellyer
2005 Year in Rerview
2005
In Defense of the NEP
Harper's Errors in Logic
State of the Disunion Address
LPCA Convention, featuring Jean Lapierre
2004
2004 Recap
Gay Marriage
Gun Registry
Paul Martin's First Year
Provincial Debate Recap
French Debate Recap
Ill-Fated Atttempts at Humour
Tim Hudak's math problem
Tim Hortons versus the UN
Exclusive: Roll Up The Attack Ads
How the Grinch Prorogued Parliament
You too, can be an anonymous Liberal
A Letter from the Nigerian Prince
Stelmach Fixed Election Dates
Black versus Female Presidents
Resistance is Futile
Where Jim Dinning Stands
Fantasy Leadership
Memories
Assymetrical Advertising
Belinda's Love Life
The Race To Decentralize
Why Did The Chicken Cross The Road?
Stampede Fashion Roundup
2005,
2006,
2007,
2008,
2009,
2010,
2011
Person of the Year
2010,
2009,
2008,
2007,
2006,
2005,
2004
Contests
Moment of the Decade
Canada's Silliest Scandal
Canada's Biggest Election
Canada's Best Premier
Greatest Prime Minister...We Never Had
The Greatest Prime Minister
CalgaryGrit Hall of Fame
Jean Lapierre
Ralph Klein
Better Know a Riding
Saanich Gulf Islands
Papineau
Central Nova
Bart's Books
Deadly Fall
Chretien Memoirs
Mulroney's Memoirs
Rick Mercer Report
French Kiss
Black Swan
The Way it Works
Democracy Derailed
Right Side Up
Fun with Numbers
2011 Election by numbers
2011 Election Seat Projections
Seat Projections
2008 Conservative Vote
2008 Liberal Vote
Liberal-NDP merger (2011 update)
The Impact of By Elections
2008 CPC Breakthroughs
2008 Liberal Breakthroughs
National Battleground?
Incumbency Effects
2006 Liberal Leadership Projections
Perils of Strategic Voting
10 Comments:
Well brilliant! After all, Harper never promised anything more than a motion on the issue (followed by a Blair-like civil registry if it passed).
I'm not convinced that the counting is correct though. At least twelve members of Martin's former cabinet have voted both ways on the issue (Hello! Joe Volpe! Are you out there?). Logic really doesn't apply here and, freed of the whip, they might just change their minds again. Of course, I expect that more than a few who voted Nay last time might find it convenient to be on a fact-finding mission in Aruba (Hi Paul Zed! Wave!) when the matter comes up.
By Anonymous, at 2:14 p.m.
It will be so far down the priority list that another election will be underway before it shows up again. TG
By TonyGuitar, at 3:43 p.m.
Abortion, same sex, Israel, International terrorism will not come up until they form a majority. you are going to see a muzzled Stockwell Day and no wonder they are not giving him Foregin affairs!
By Anonymous, at 3:56 p.m.
Harper will hold a free vote on same-sex marriage, and it will result in same sex marriage being allowed, although preserving the traditional definition of marriage will get more that 130 votes. By my count it will get 145-150, it'll be close.
This *should* please both the people that he promised the free vote to, and those who want same-sex marriage to be allowed. Then Harper can declare the matter finished.
Hopefully after that, the Liberals will let the issue die, but I'm sure they'll still try to dig it up as a wedge issue.
By Michael Fox, at 4:34 p.m.
Liberals should declare it to be a dead issue, and abstain. If Harper wants to bring forward a bill, let him do it. That's what leadership is about.
If he brings forward a bill, then I would suggest it should be defeated.
By Anonymous, at 7:22 p.m.
i hate wedge issues. wedge issues are called wedge issues because they act like an AX being thrust into the cohesiveness of canada. they cause gaping cleavages that run across political affiliation, families, and friends. if a party says its not going to be an issue, we should take them on their word. that way if they do end up legislating on it, they will have to face the electorate that they lied to. there was plenty of real policy to criticise in the tory platform. if the liberal criticisms were not making traction, than accept that the canadian public is ok with some their ideas. it is not ok to start trying to brand them with an identity that doesn't really belong to them. and now, because they have won, they will forge their record to disprove all the fear mongering, and it will be harder to defeat them on policy next time. it really is self defeating.
By Anonymous, at 8:04 p.m.
My conclusion is the same. Harper's found a compromise between progays and traditionalists. He'll be able to say he's standing up for democracy with the free vote, protecting gay marriage cuz it won't get repealed, and for the traditionalists he can say he gave them a shot. Harper wants this out of the way to show he and the CPC are ok.
I'd argue a large majority will vote pro-gay marriage though; not a close call like the Toronto Tory said.
I posted the ideas on my centrist blog, centrerion.blogspot.com (majority vs minority), and on my diary at progressive bloggers.
Nice to see someone popular has the same thoughts.
By lecentre, at 9:29 p.m.
Harper will only be happy if his anti-SSM MPs do the math and realize that calling a free vote on SSM is a terrible idea.
But it only takes one innumerate idiot to fail to do the math and call a free vote anyway. The only question is, which innumerate moron Conservative MP will do it? There are ever so many possibilities.
By Anonymous, at 7:48 p.m.
Maybe. The question will be framed differently by the Conservatives in government than the Liberals did. According to Paul Martin, the Charter requires SSM, so he asked, "Who's against the Charter of Rights and Freedoms?"
The Conservatives, on the other hand, will offer MPs a choice: "Do you support SSM, or would you prefer civil unions plus traditional marriage?"
Also, the PM won't be twisting arms of Liberal MPs this time. Thus it is entirely possible that we will see SSM rejected by many more Liberals than last time.
By Anonymous, at 7:02 a.m.
The issue is not done yet.
By satin shirt, at 7:42 a.m.
Post a Comment
<< Home