This story caught my eye, if only because it was one of the policies debated, and defeated on the final day at the Liberal convention last weekend.
This is the type of thing I’ve been in favour of for a long time. I really believe the tax code should be modified to reward healthy and environmentally sound choices and to punish poor ones. But after listening to the debate on the topic, I’m now firmly against tax breaks for gym memberships. Why? Because it would amount to nothing more than a tax break for rich, white people. Let’s face it, how many low income single mothers buy gym memberships? The best exercise can sometimes be a jog around the block (or, from my personal experience, running away from a mob of angry gun owners who’ve spotted that Liberal sign on your front lawn).
A fairer way to go about things would be to bring in a “fat tax”. Tax junk foods, fast foods, and fatty/unhealthy foods. I think this is a far better solution than rewarding those who (somewhat ironically) drive across town twice a week in January to walk on a treadmill for an hour.
10 Comments:
Valid points Matt, but I'm sticking behind two things:
1. People who use gyms are generally middle to upper class. If you're working extra to support your family, or are a single mom, you don't have time to go to the gym.
2. A fat tax would work. "Neccesity" foods would be exempt and if poor people buy junk food instead of the basics, then that's their problem. But, at least, it would hit everyone with unhealthy habits, rather than only helping the upper class which I maintain the gym vouchers would do.
Finally, I don't think the gym idea would work. Sure, more people might buy gym memberships in January if they got a tax break, but where's the incensite to not give up in February? Considering it's even less of a sunk cost, I don't think people would be motivated to stick with it. If I've put down 200$ for a yearly membership, I'm more likely to get my "money's worth", than if I only put down 50$.
I do like the intent behind this, but I really don't think it would work.
By calgarygrit, at 4:23 p.m.
"1. Why is bad if gym vouchers end up only helping the middle class?"
-Because inevitably, if money is spent on giving them tax breaks, there's less cash to go around for social programs or low income tax breaks.
"2. Why is it ok if the poor with unhealty eating habits are made poorer?"
-To encourage them to eat healthier. The same reason the poor who smoke pay cigarette taxes.
"3. If a single mom doesn't have time to go to the gym, she doesn't have time to run around the block in -20 weather, so why are we kicking this example around?"
-The point here is that there are a lot of ways to get in shape other than buying a gym pass. What if someone works construction? Should they get a benefit too? What if someone bike's to work every morning?
And even if more people BUY gym passes, are we sure this will encourage them to use it. If the sunk cost is less, it seems to me they'd be less motivated to go to the gym.
By calgarygrit, at 3:31 p.m.
Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a earn extra income idea site. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
By Anonymous, at 11:07 a.m.
This cannot have effect in fact, that is what I believe.
By www.soria-3d.com, at 9:31 a.m.
ymj oca lamination machine |
mobile repairing course in delhi |
mobile repairing course karol bagh |
mobile repairing course raipur |
mobile repairing course in ranchi |
led tv repairing course in delhi |
mobile repairing course in delhi |
mobile repairing course in delhi |
laptop repairing institute in patna |
laptop repairing institute
By Roksy, at 7:56 a.m.
Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge with everyone...
samsung mobile IC price
laptop repairing course in delhi
printer repairing course in patna
By Roksy, at 3:12 a.m.
AK Info is the premier led & lcd repairing courses in Patna. We provide the best LED & LCD television repair courses. We have experienced teaching faculty for the courses. Our training classroom is equipped with advance technology.
LCD TV repairing courses in Patna
By Roksy, at 3:29 a.m.
Best Mobile Repairing Course in Delhi, Join AK info - No. 1 Mobile Phone Repairing Training Institute in New Delhi, India, Admission Open, Visit Now!
led tv repairing course in patna
mobile repairing institute
laptop repairing course in delhi
best mobile repair in ranchi
laptop repair course
mobile repairing course
By Roksy, at 5:01 a.m.
mobile repairing course online you will get training for mobile hardware and mobile software solution.
mobile repairing online course in jamshedpur
laptop repairing online course in ranchi
mobile repairing online course
laptop repairing online classes
mobile repairing online course in muzaffarpur
mobile repair online course in delhi
best mobile repairing online course in india
best mobile repairing online course in delhi
laptop repairing online course in muzaffarpur
mobile repairing online course in new delhi
mobile repairing online course in new delhi
mobile repairing institute online courses
mobile repairing online course in new delhi
mobile repairing online course in aurangabad
mobile repairing online course in patna
mobile repairing online course in delhi fees
computer hardware online course in patna
mobile repairing software online courses
By Roksy, at 5:47 a.m.
mobile repairing course is based on practical learning approach and classes, hence our mobile repairing courses are designed in a way that learner get full exposure to handle all types of mobiles
mobile repair online courses
chip level laptop repairing online course
mobile phone repairing courses online
chip level repairing course online
best mobile repairing institute in delhi
mobile repairing online course in india
mobile repairing online course in bangalore
mobile repairing online course near me
smart phones repair training courses online
mobile training online courses
laptop repair online course in patna
laptop repairing online course in delhi
By Roksy, at 8:45 a.m.
Post a Comment
<< Home