Primary Debates
While I've already voiced my support for this system, Jeff raises three valid critiques which I want to take the time to rebut - one logistical, one conceptual, and one on the decision-making process.
1) Logistical: "One concern is the potential for shenanigans; supporters of another party signing up as Liberal “supporters” to vote in the primary and negatively influence the process, such as voting for the least-favoured candidate."
Again, I point to the Alberta Liberal example, where such shenanigans were tried (against a much weaker party) and failed spectacularly.
The reason for this is simple enough - most people don't give a big enough damn to try something like this, and those who do are too high profile to risk getting caught. Finding 50,000 rabble rousers willing to sign up and make Tony Genco the next Liberal leader simply can't be done under the radar, and whoever tried to organize a campaign like this would seriously hurt their credibility.
Seventeen US states let Democrats vote in Republican primaries and vice versa. Their rationale is that a candidate who earns primary votes from across the aisle, will also earn general election votes from across the aisle. If Karl Rove can't find a way to get Denis Kucinich the Democratic nomination, then I don't think we have much to fear here.
I know some are concerned about special interest groups taking over a nomination meeting, but a $10 membership fee isn't going to stop them - if anything, a supporter system makes a takeover harder since it takes more votes to win. If an anti-abortion group goes from needing 100 votes to 120 votes to win a nomination meeting, it makes it that much more difficult for them to get their candidate of choice nominated (remembering of course that all candidates still need to be green lit by the party).
2) Conceptual: "One of the key incentives for joining a political party is the opportunity to vote in leadership and nomination races. This proposal devalues membership. Already, during each successive election, it has become harder to get Liberals to volunteer to knock on doors, stuff envelopes, and get out the vote. We need committed members, and more of them, to successfully rebuild this party."
Here's the thing. By itself, party membership means nothing. The point of signing someone up to be a member is to get their contact information so that you can get them to knock on doors, stuff envelopes, and get out the vote. I agree we need more of these people, but the way you get them is by making it easier to join the Liberal fold. Consider the supporter system a gateway drug to lure liberal-minded Canadians into the big red tent (and yes, I totally intend to put that line, creepy as it is, on a button at the Ottawa convention). Once they've registered, they can be invited to become full fledged members, volunteer, and donate money.
Yes, we need to make membership meaningful to retain and engage members. But if we want to grow the membership, we need to tear down the barriers to becoming involved, and a primary system would do just that. You don't think a few of the millions who signed up to vote for Barack Obama in the 2008 primaries also gave their money and time to get him elected in the ensuing general election?
I know many are uneasy about "instant Liberals", but if this change means thousands of new Canadians pouring into our ranks, then that's fantastic. There are instant Liberals I signed up for leadership votes who are now more involved in the party than I am.
3) The Process: "The party executive wants to amend the constitution so the new leadership selection process can be adopted at the biennial convention in Ottawa January 13-15, 2012, barely two months from now. Meetings to elect delegates to that convention are happening now, and many are being cancelled and the delegates acclaimed due to a lack of people willing to fill all the available spots. It’s not as if this concept has been debated in Liberal circles for months. We’re just getting this now. We’re talking about fundamentally changing the most important thing we do—selecting a leader—and we’re rushing into it."
I know the Liberal response to every problem is to call a Royal Commission, but this gives delegates to the January convention two months to debate the idea - plenty of time to make up their minds. Liberals have talked about "renewal" for years without anything happening - it's time to get off the pot or shift the way we do politics.
The reality is we need to lay down the ground rules for the next leadership race before we find ourselves in the next leadership race. We're now a third party, and a series of rolling primaries would add much needed excitement to the contest, helping us introduce the next leader to Canadians.
I don't think the end result would be any different under one-member-one-vote or the registered supporter system. But, like Jeff says, process matters, and this new way of electing leaders would send a message to Canadians that the Liberal Party is willing to change and open itself up to Canadians.
UPDATE: Jeff responds to my responds here, to which I respond here and he responds here. At this point, I call him and argue Hitler was against a primary system, to which he calls me a redneck and hangs up. Let's agree to disagree and call it a draw.
Labels: primary system
90 Comments:
In my brief experience of membership in the Liberal Party, the point of membership was so that you'd get hit up for money every month or so.
Non-membership was much more pleasant and I remained just as involved in campaigns.
By
Brian Henry, at 9:58 a.m.
Having had policy discussions punted to late 2013 or even 2014, what rights the Roadmap gives to party members regarding the design, passage and implementation of party policy is a critical aspect. The Roadmap does not represent any change in this area; there is no empowerment of the LPC members or new Supporters in this critical area; the old system of All animals are equal but some are more equal than others is continued.
This lack of remedy for this obvious democratic deficit in itself is reason enough to be concerned about the rush to change. Perhaps it is time to slow the train down a bit and peer into its insides ...
By
CuriosityCat, at 10:40 a.m.
Dan,
On the shenanigans angle, I won’t try to elevate it the level of a major risk. It is, however, an issue to be aware of. And there are indeed ways to mitigate it. I think regional weighting, for example, makes it a lot hard than it would be under a purely open system, as you’d have to move numbers in ridings across the country.
The Alberta case was interesting. Ironically, I believe many conservative PCers feel small-l liberals used their anyone can join at any time model to help propel Redford into office. On the ALP, there may have been a half-hearted attempt but with the ALP even more of a non-entity than the LPC, why would anyone really bother? Maybe if they were a more credible threat; that’s purely speculative though. What isn’t, though, is that the ALP primary didn’t generate the waves of excitement and participation that proponents hoped for, and that LPC primary proponents are predicting if we adopt it federally. It wasn’t a bang, but a whimper.
And if you want to draw on a U.S. example of primary shenanigans, how about Wisconsin Republicans putting up “fake Democrats” as primary candidates? It may not happen much at the presidential level, but Democrats and Republicans regularly play such games for other federal, state and local offices, although usually not as blatantly.
Anyway, if they want to try a takeover I’d rather at least have their $10. ;)
On value of membership, a primary system does nothing to tear down any of the barriers to membership, and it makes membership less valuable and attractive at the same time. We do need to tear down barriers to membership, and I’ve made several suggestions in that regard. Accessible riding associations, member-driven policy, that’s how you engage and retain members. Creating a separate membership-lite supporter class doesn’t tear down a single barrier, unless you consider a $10 fee and having to call yourself a Liberal being a barrier to being, you know, a Liberal. Let’s tear down the real barriers and get them to join, for real.
I liked your drug analogy, so here’s another creepy expression for you: why would they buy the cow when you’re giving them the milk for free?
On process, I don’t think wanting to take longer that two months (with the holiday season thrown in for good measure) to consider a change sprung on us out of the blue by an outgoing executive really equates to wanting a Royal Commission.
Yes, we have talked about renewal for years. However, a) we haven’t been talking about primaries, and b) sorry, things have happened. We were both in Vancouver a few years ago when delegates adopted one member, one vote, after years of thorough, full and proper debate not just by delegates, but by all party members. This was a major achievement of renewal and reform, and although some are ready to throw it out without even trying it once, and while it may be easier for some to argue against a delegated system that no longer exists, let’s not pretend it didn’t happen.
Look, I know there is a great appetite for change in the Liberal Party. But change for change’s sake is foolish, and just because something is new doesn’t mean its better. Instead of being presented with an amendment from Alf Apps and the current board and being told you’re in favour of “reform” or you hate the troops, we should take the time to consider this properly and think it through.
Whether you support the end-game or not, rushing the process is still wrong.
Finally, let me end by saying as long as we don’t have good ideas and an idea of what we as a party stand for and what we want to be and do, all the rolling primaries in the world aren’t going to generate any interest. It would merely be flash over substance, and that’s the same mistake we continually make in this party.
By
Jeff, at 12:29 p.m.
The attempt to hijack the Alberta Liberal Party failed because it wasn't nessessary.
Alberta Liberals seemed quite willing to elect the worst candidate possible without outside help.
By
Frank, at 1:00 p.m.
I think regional weighting, for example, makes it a lot hard than it would be under a purely open system, as you’d have to move numbers in ridings across the country.
Doesn't that make it easier? You can hijack a lot more 50-member RAs than 500-member ones.
By
Anonymous, at 1:03 p.m.
Thanks for the response Jeff.
I agree on the final point you raise. A flashy primary system won't make up for a lack of substance, but I do think if we have some substance to back it up, a primary system could help showcase this substance. Regardless, I don't think anyone would argue this is a panacea or should be done instead of other renewal options.
As for the other points:
1. The Republican shenanigans you mentioned FAILED and "fake" candidates would never pass a green light committee regardless. Like you said, not a huge threat.
2. On Alberta, the Alberta Liberals still doubled the votes from their 2008 leadership race. I won't say that was all because of the primary system, but that's hardly a wimper.
And you still have to pay for a PC membership, so if Liberals got Redford elected, that's hardly a strike against a supporter system.
3. On value for membership, the end goal isn't getting people to pay $10 for a membership - it's getting them to advocate about the party to their friends, volunteer, and donate money. If it takes some free milk to get them to do that, then let's give out some free milk. We get their contact info and data when they're a supporter, all we lose is their $10.
And I do think there is a bit of a psychological barrier to joining a political party just as there is to joining any organization. The spin will be the Liberals have opened the party and are encouraging all Canadians to participate in the selection of the next Liberal leader - that might make some of the millions who vote Liberal but have never taken out a Liberal membership at least consider signing up.
4. On timelines, was there really a lot more than a 2 month debate on WOMOV? I mean, the primary idea has been talked about informally for years, was floated to the media this summer, and has been formally released 2 months before convention. I don't think there was much debate on WOMOV until at least February 2009 when the coalition crisis had passed.
People should be able to make up their minds in 2 months, especially since this proposal will have a lot more buzz around it than most constitutional ammendments.
I've criticized Apps on many occasions, but I'm willing to consider the proposal on its merits because I know the idea has been advanced by a lot of grassroots Liberals at renewal workshops since the election too. In the end, Liberals, not the national executive, will vote on it so this isn't a case of a new system being imposed on us.
By
calgarygrit, at 1:06 p.m.
I would ban anyone who has given to another political party from voting in these primaries. This measure would lessen the potential for games, because it removes the hardcore partisans, who are engaged and most apt to mess around.
Jeff is right when he says we need ideas, primaries won't motivate. However, if we have someone with an attractive message, this process allows for a "spark" that can resonate beyond the small circle of Liberals. Primaries will go nowhere without people armed with compelling ideas, but primaries can go farther if we have people with compelling ideas.
By
Steve V, at 1:18 p.m.
Anon,
You can hijack a lot more 50-member RAs than 500-member ones.
If it's purely open, you can sign up members anywhere you can get them. They could all be in Toronto. The number of members in a riding is irrelevant if it's pure, unweighted OMOV. Only the raw numbers matter.
In a weighted model, either primary or WOMOV, 1k members in one Toronto riding only gets you one riding out of 308. To be successful you'd need to build an organization across the country. And finding mischief makers in a few hundred ridings across the country is a lot bigger organizational and logistical challenge than doing a mass sign-up in your backyard.
Dan,
1. That the US example failed wasn't the point. I was trying to counter the proposition that shenanigans don't occur in the US system. Successful or not (and they don't always fail), they do happen.
2. And the NDP just tripled their membership in Quebec. But you don't need to be a stats major to know why such figures can be highly misleading... :)
3. There are many other ways to build a database. We have opened up the voting with OMOV, and yet most people seem determined to argue against a delegated system that no longer exists, except to pass this reform, of course.
I'm not concerned at all what spin media and our opponents would care to put on whatever we do. It would be ironic, since the CPC has the same system we do now; the NDP is unweighted WOMOV. The haters will hate whatever we do. We should do what we thing is right, whether it's primaries or OMOV, and potential spin shouldn't be a consideration.
My bottom line is I don't see that big a psychological barrier between members and supporter so that 1ks of people are going to flock to help pick the leader of the third party that wouldn't have otherwise. But I see a lot of negatives I've already outlined.
4. OMOV was debated in various forms going back at least to 2005. It was debated and defeated in an unweighted version in Montreal in 2006, and debated over the years that followed and during the aborted 2008 leadership race before being adopted in Vancouver in 2009. That's at least four years and two conventions worth of debate. That's a lot more than two months.
How many ridings have held meetings to debate a primary? How many will before thise that can afford to be delegates go and decide in January.
I hope some will, but I fear many won't. And while we're trying to build the base, leaving a lot of people out would be a step backward.
By
Jeff, at 1:25 p.m.
I would ban anyone who has given to another political party from voting in these primaries
That would make it pretty awkward for certain leadership and presidential candidates.
By
Anonymous, at 1:38 p.m.
It's ridiculous that any of these proposals are being put forth prior to consultation with any then voting on by the PTAs. Hell, LPCO hasn't even had an AGM since Feb. 2010. Which means the greateast amount of Liberal members are not even being asked to vote on such notions prior to a national convention. It also means that Ontario Libs will not be ringing forth any of their own resolutions.
We havent even had aleadeership vote by WOMOV yet and we want to trash it? Really Dan? So much for our hard fought road to get 'er done in 2009 where we had failed in 2006. Let's just spit on the memory of all those that spent years getting that through.
By
James Curran, at 3:11 p.m.
oops that should rear "any of them being voted on"
By
James Curran, at 3:12 p.m.
To the first point about shenanigans, it does take place. Living in Texas (one of those states where you don't register by party and where you can vote in any party's primary), it happens.
I can personally attest to receiving phone calls from people in 2008 who were Republicans who voted in the Democratic primary just to try and mess with the Democrats (they were calling to get off Democratic mailing lists). There was an effort by conservative talk radio hosts to try and get Republicans to vote in the Democratic primary.
Is it enough to swing who gets nominated? No. There are other factors that decide the nomination (at least here), and Republicans voting in Democratic primaries and vice versa isn't one of them.
To make a long story short, shenanigans happen, but I don't think it's ever decided a nomination.
By
JMiddleton, at 3:15 p.m.
James - I'd argue the primary system is just an extension of WOMOV, in that:
1) It would be weighted by riding
2) It ends delegated conventions
The only difference is that you go from members voting to supporters voting.
So it's not undoing or replacing WOMOV. It's just improving it by making it more open.
By
calgarygrit, at 3:56 p.m.
And as for consultation, what I'd like to see would be some kind of online straw poll of all members on these changes before the convention. It would be cheap and easy to do, and would give some direction to the delegates on what the grassroots think.
Beyond that, the convention is basically where members are being consulted. If this proposal doesn't get 2/3 support, it won't happen. I agree it feels a bit more top down than I'd like it to feel, but this isn't being imposed on Liberals - it's merely being put on the agenda to be debated and voted on.
By
calgarygrit, at 3:58 p.m.
Yeah. Haven't tried one way yet, so let's improve on something not yet attempted. I have no clue as to why the Liberal Party bothers to write trivial rules and constitutions. We clearly have no intention of following them any time in the near future.
By
James Curran, at 4:05 p.m.
If it's purely open, you can sign up members anywhere you can get them. They could all be in Toronto. The number of members in a riding is irrelevant if it's pure, unweighted OMOV. Only the raw numbers matter.
I know.
That's why it's easier to hijack a weighted-riding system than an unweighted one. You get a bunch of Tom Long members down in Gaspé, and you're in business.
Signup-for-signup, you are better off organizing the living snot out of defunct or moribund ridings in unfertile and rural ground, than you are in trying to hijack the party in areas where it is strong and has large numbers of active members or eligible voters to begin with.
By
Anonymous, at 10:17 p.m.
>>>>
get off the pot or shift
Sometimes U really bring a smile to my face
By
JBV, at 12:35 p.m.
As per usual, Steve V is a partisan idiot
Fact: Steve V doesn't care about the population or the system or the country - he cares about the LPC
By
JBV, at 12:37 p.m.
You may want to have a look at James Morton's thoughts on the matter at http://www.jamesforvp.ca/the-primary-option-open-nominations-open-society/
By
Carey Miller, at 10:18 p.m.
The first thing to visit this blog is useful information and add our insight and knowledge for us all thank you admin..toko jaket kulit visit my website
By
Unknown, at 2:30 p.m.
Hello! This topic has been something that I have been looking for a few hours. I want to write a research paper about those elections and your information is very useful for me. Please keep it good posting. I can recommend my favorite custom-paper-writing.org helper as the best solution for all paper troubles for students from all over the world.
By
Mark, at 6:50 a.m.
Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future. keep sharing
www.baixar-whatsapp.com.br
By
Linda, at 12:52 a.m.
nice article and it is very helpful me and my friends
youraadhar
By
Unknown, at 9:21 p.m.
I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: mutilateadoll2game.com. What about you?
By
Unknown, at 4:21 a.m.
This is extremely helpful info!! Very good work. Everything is very interesting to learn and easy to understood. Thank you for giving information.
abcya | hooda games
By
hooda games, at 11:31 a.m.
شركة مكافحة البق براس الخيممة
شركة تنظيف مسابح بعجمان
شركة تنظيف سجاد بالبخار بعجمان
تنظيف موكيت بالبخار بعجمان
شركة تنظيف كنب بالبخار فى عجمان
شركة تنظيف ستائر بالبخار بعجمان
شركة تنظيف بالبخار بعجمان
تنظيف بالبخار فى بعجمان
شركة نظافة فى عجمان
شركة تنظيف بعجمان
شركات تنظيف فلل بعجمان
شركات تنظيف المبانى فى بعجمان
شركة تنظيف شقق فى بعجمان
شركة تنظيف منازل فى بعجمان
شركة مكافحة حشرات بعجمان
شركة مكافحة الصراصير بعجمان
شركة مكافحة الفئران بعجمان
شركة مكافحة الرمة بعجمان
شركة مكافحة البق بعجمان
By
elkamaal, at 3:08 p.m.
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
افضل شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شركات شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
حقين اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شركات اثاث مستعمل بالخبر
By
elkamaal, at 4:39 p.m.
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
افضل شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شركات شراء اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
حقين اثاث مستعمل بالدمام
شركات اثاث مستعمل بالخبر
By
elkamaal, at 4:48 p.m.
شركة تنظيف يمكة
شركة نظافة بمكة
شركة تنظيف شقق بمكة
شركة تنظيف بيوت بمكة
شركة تنظيف منازل بمكة
شركة تنظيف فلل بمكة
شركة تنظيف بالبخار بمكة
شركة تنظيف سجاد بالبخار بمكة
شركة تنظيف سجاد بمكة
شركة تنظيف موكيت بمكة
شركة تنظيف موكيت بالبخار بمكة
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالبخار بمكة
By
elkamaal, at 4:56 p.m.
شركة شحن بري من مصر للسعودية
شركة شحن من مصر للسعودية
شركات شحن بري من مصر للسعودية
شركات شحن بضائع من مصر للسعودية
شركات الشحن الدولى من مصر الى السعودية
شركة شحن من مصر للسعودية
شركة نقل برى من مصر الى السعودية
شركات الشحن فى مصر
By
elkamaal, at 4:58 p.m.
شركة تنظيف بالاحساء
شركات النظافة بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف فلل بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف منازل بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف بيوت بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف شقق بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف كنب بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف سجاد بالاحساء
شركة نظافة بالاحساء
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالاحساء
ارقام شركات تنظيف بالاحساء
ارقام شركات تنظيف منازل بالاحساء
شركة المثالية للتنظيف بالاحساء
شركة كشف تسربات بالاحساء
By
elkamaal, at 5:09 p.m.
شركة مكافحة الصراصير بدبى
شركة مكافحة حشرات بدبى
شركة مبيدات حشرية في دبي
افضل شركة مكافحة الحشرات في الامارات
مكافحة بق الفراش فى دبى
شركة مكافحة الفئران بدبى
شركة مكافحة النمل الأبيض بدبى
شركة مكافحة الرمة بدبى
شركة مكافحة حشرات دبى
مكافحة حشرات فى دبى
افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات بدبى
By
elkamaal, at 5:11 p.m.
شركة مكافحة حشرات بجازان
شركة رش مبيدات بجازان
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بجازان
شركة مكافحة الفئران بجازان
شركة مكافحة القوارض بجاران
شركة كشف تسربات بجازان
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بجازان
كشف تسربات المياه بجازان بدون تكسير
شركة تنظيف خزانات بجازان
تنظيف خزانات بجازان
شركة عزل خزانات بجازان
غسيل خزانات بجازان
شركة تنظيف بجازان
By
elkamaal, at 5:25 p.m.
شركة تسليك مجارى بالاحساء
تسليك مجارى بالاحساء
نفخ المجارى بالاحساء
رقم مصلحة المجارى بالاحساء
طوارىء الصرف الصحى بالاحساء
المثالية لتسليك المجارى بالاحساء
شركة عزل اسطح بالاحساء
شركة عزل حرارى بالاحساء
شركة عزل فوم بالاحساء
شركة عزل مائى بالاحساء
By
elkamaal, at 5:29 p.m.
كثير من النساء ليس لديهم الوقت الكافي لتنظيف منزلها، لذا لابد أن تتعامل مع شركة مخصصة في مجال التنظيف، حيث تعتبر شركة تنظيف موكيت بالبخار الشارقة
التاج الملكي شركة تنظيف كنب بالبخار الشارقة
أفضل شركة تنظيف الشارقة
، فتقوم هذه الشركة خدمت تنظيف الشارقة
بعمل نظافة كاملة لجميع الأغراض المنزلية في المنزل، فتعتبر شركة تنظيف فى الشارقة
من أكبر الشركات التي تعمل في التنظيف في مدينة الشارقة لما توفره من مميزات وخدمات لعملائها، فتعمل شركة تنظيف الشارقة
على تنظيف كل ما يخص المنازل والبيوت ولديها أحدث أدوات ومعدات التعقيم لترتيب العديد من الغرف في البيوت، لأنها تعمل على تنظيف البيوت من الأتربة التي توجد بداخلها وإزالتها نهائياً.
أهم الخدمات والمميزات التي تقدمها التاج الملكى خدمات تنظيف الشارقة
تعتبر التاج الملكى شركة تنظيف بالشارقة
من الشركات الرائدة في مجال التنظيف، فتقدم العديد من الخدمات والمميزات، غير أن شركة تنظيف بالبخار الشارقة
تقوم بعمل جميع هذه الخدمات وبأسعار تنافس جميع الشركات الأخرى، حيث نعرض لكم اليوم جميع الخدمات والمميزات التي تقوم بها شركة تنظيف منازل الشارقة
و شركات تنظيف المبانى الشارقة
.
• تقدم شركة تنظيف مسابح الشارقة
العديد من الخدمات وبأسعار رخيصة للغاية ونظراً لسعرها الرائع فهي تجذب العديد من العملاء، فتقوم شركة تنظيف شقق الشارقة
بعمل خصومات رائعة في مجال التنظيف يصل الخصومات إلى 50% عن السعر المخصص للتنظيف في الشركات الأخرى التي تعمل في هذا المجال.
• وتمتلك شركة تنظف فلل الشارقة
العديد من الأساليب الحديثة، ويوجد لديها فريق عمل متمكن في مجال التنظيف، فلا توظف أحد من العمال إلا أن يكون حاصل على شهادة الأيزو العالمية في مجال التنظيف ويكون خبرة ذو خمس سنوات على الأقل، فتتوفر في العمالة في شركات تنظيف المنازل الشارقة
الخبرة والدقة في الأداء والعمل لذا تعتبر من أكبر الشركات المتخصصة في هذا المجال.
By
elkamaal, at 5:41 p.m.
what is conveyed here is easy to understand. thank you and success
Cara Menyembuhkan Diare
Cara Mengatasi Kolik Ginjal
Pengobatan Sindrom Reye
Cara Menghilangkan Benjolan Wasir
Cara Mengobati Infeksi Gusi
Pengobatan Kista Ginjal
By
Unknown, at 5:00 a.m.
the information on this page gives me benefits, thank you very much
Cara Mengobati Tumor Tulang Kaki
Obat Tradisional Kanker Rongga Mulut
Obat Tradisional Gangguan Fungsi Hati
Obat Tradisional Penyakit Lupus
Obat Leher Kaku Tengeng
By
Cara Mengobati Dengkul Yang Bengkak, at 2:53 a.m.
highly awaited new information from this site
Good luck !!
tanaman obat fatty liver
efek bahaya kanker hati
By
Unknown, at 3:10 a.m.
Here is one very useful information
Gejala Penyakit Batu Empedu
Makanan Yang Dianjurkan Bagi Penderita Batu Empedu
Obat Prostat Alami Tanpa Operasi
Gejala Penyakit Prostat Pada Pria
Makanan Yang Sehat Untuk Penderita Bronkitis
Tanaman Untuk Mengatasi Bronkitis
By
Unknown, at 3:38 a.m.
foods that can prevent throat cancer
By
Makanan Yang Bisa Mencegah Kanker Tenggorokan, at 3:19 a.m.
ow, you are very good in the social field and your website is interesting and up-to-date
don't forget to visit our website :) :)
Khasiat Tanaman Obat Khusus Penderita Penyakit Jantung Bocor
Pantangan Makanan Penyakit Jantung Bocor
Pantangan Makanan Penyakit Jantung Bocor
Bahaya Penyakit Jantung bocor Yang Harus Anda Patut Diwaspadai
Penanganan Dan Pencegahan Jantung Bocor Yang Harus Anda Ketahui
By
Unknown, at 4:55 a.m.
Your comment is very unusual and interesting again, thank you, thank you
Olahraga Yang Baik Untuk Pasien Penderita Jantung
5 Macam Obat Tradisional Jantung Bocor Paling Ampuh
TIPS MENYEMBUHKAN JANTUNG BOCOR PADA ANAK ANAK DAN DEWASA
APAKAH BENAR JANTUNG BOCOR MENYEBABKAN KEMATIAN?
PENYEBAB GEJALA DAN PENGOBATAN JANTUNG BOCOR
Apakah Jantung Bocor Pada Usia Bayi Bisa Sembuh?
By
Unknown, at 4:57 a.m.
This website is very worth visiting because it often provides interesting information.
Cara Mengobati Lutut Bengkak
Obat Herbal Sindrom Tourette
Obat Tradisional Asam Urat
Obat Alami Leukimia
By
walatraherbal07, at 10:13 p.m.
information that is very useful and also very much needed by many people, if you please please visit my website, thank you mamen
Cara Mengobati Kanker Lidah
Obat Penyempitan Jantung
Obat Tiroid Herbal
Obat Stroke Trombotik Herbal
Cara Mengobati Gondok Beracun
Cara Mengobati Bronkitis
By
Unknown, at 12:11 a.m.
A neat and useful post
Cara Alami Menghilangkan Jerawat Pasir Dengan Cepat
Obat Maag yang Aman Untuk Ibu Hamil dan Menyusui
Cara Mengobati Tulang Belakang Terasa Sakit Saat Bangun Tidur
By
Unknown, at 3:27 a.m.
sharing is indeed beautiful, now you have various information that is very useful for readers of this article. continue to share the information I'm waiting for.
do not forget also here my various health information.
Cara Mengobati Radang Usus Besar
Cara Cepat Mengobati Infeksi Usus Besar
Hindari Kebiasaan Yang Menyebabkan Batu Ginjal
By
Anonymous, at 8:52 p.m.
Thanks for the information, in tunggua keep the latest news
cara mengatasi sakit dada sebelah kiri
obat epilepsi tradisional
By
phefoc, at 12:13 a.m.
Thanks for best article was given to me. Keep your best content then share to other people sothat they can know what your informed. Try to visit my page below. Good be with us, good luck.
Pengobatan Herbal Penyakit Gondok Tanpa Operasi
Cara Mengatasi Rasa Mual Dan Muntah
Mengatasi Nyeri Panggul Secara Herbal
Cara Mengobati Pembengkakan Hati Secara Herbal
Obat Herbal Rabun Dekat 100% Ampuh
By
Unknown, at 5:14 a.m.
Thanks for the information presented on your website
Very in waiting for other information
obat tradisional plantar fasciitis
obat tradisional kanker usus
By
Unknown, at 12:33 a.m.
we provide information about health, hopefully it can be useful to you all
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Hepatoma
Cara Menyembuhkan Penyakit Orchitis
Obat Herbal Sakit Kepala Tegang Berkepanjangan
Obat Tulang Retak Dan Bengkak
Salep Penghilang Bekas Gatal Yang Menghitam
By
Lia Aliana, at 3:39 a.m.
Thanks for the information. I am enthusiastic about the information you make
Cara Mendiagnosis Penyakit Hepatitis A
Penyebab Hepatitis A Yang Sering Anda Abaikan
Apakah Penyakit Hepatitis A Menular?
Cara Penularan Hepatitis B Yang Harus Kamu Ketahui
Penyebab Penyakit Hepatitis B dan Pengobatan Hepatitis B Terampuh
Bahaya Hepatitis B Bagi Ibu Hamil
Ini Faktanya Jika Penderita Hepatitis B Masih Bisa Hidup Normal
Inilah Artinya Jika Hasil HBsAg Positif
Wajib Waspada Terhadap Penyakit Hepatitis Alkoholik
By
Unknown, at 5:09 a.m.
jazakallah khir for the article, subhanallah .. the analogy is simple but deep meaning. something we know but we never realized, Thank you very useful information
Cara Cepat Mengobati Infeksi Usus Besar
Obat Herbal Disentri Terbaik
Penyebab Sakit Pinggang Sebelah Kiri
Cara Mengatasi Penyempitan Pembuluh Darah
Cara Menyembuhkan Pembengkakan Hat
Obat Herbal Pengerasan Hati
Obat Kista Testis Herbal Ampuh
By
Unknown, at 4:39 a.m.
Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found the information I was looking for. Once again, thank you so much.
obat prostat bengkak alami
cara mengobati kerumut
cara menghilangkan sakit kepala cluster
obat tradisional abses payudara
cara mengatasi gatal pada kulit selangkangan
obat tradisional penyakit graves
cara mengobati pitted keratolysis
cara mengatasi mastitis
cara mengobati otitis eksterna
cara memperbaiki mata ptosis
By
Pengobatan Alami Terbaik, at 4:56 a.m.
I think this website admin really works hard for the website, with the reason that every article has good quality
Apakah Penyakit Infeksi Paru-paru Berbahya ?
Obat Ginjal Alami Terbaik
Cara Mengolah Daun Salam Untuk Obat Kolesterol Tinggi
Manfaat Daun Sirsak Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Gondok
By
Unknown, at 9:31 p.m.
The latest information we are waiting for lho..semoga what is given can be useful
success always everything.
obat tradisional maag akut
obat tradisional buah zakar bengkak
obat tradisional lutut kaku
By
Unknown, at 10:14 p.m.
Sharing is not about how big and how valuable things you give, but how sincere and sincere what you want to give.
Obat Pereda Nyeri Haid
Obat Kanker Darah Tradisional
Cara Menghentikan Haid Berkepanjangan
By
Unknown, at 5:12 a.m.
Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found the information I was looking for. Once again, thank you so much.
obat herbal ampuh untuk mengatasi cacar air
cara pemesanan qnc jelly gamat secara online
cara menghilangkan benjolan seperti bisul di ketiak
obat penghilang kebas dan kesemutan alami
cara menghilangkan benjolan dimulut rahim
cara menyembuhkan fistula ani
By
Jelly Gamat Walatra, at 6:25 a.m.
The news that you present is very useful .. hopefully other news as well
You can share .. success
penyebab kanker usus dan cara mengatasinya
cara membersihkan paru paru perokok berat
obat nyeri otot paha belakang
By
Rania, at 12:06 a.m.
It's an amazing experience to be able to see quality articles from excellent webs like the ones you make.
Ciri Ciri Gondongan
By
Unknown, at 10:47 p.m.
Thanks for sharing the most amazing blogs and your website was outstanding. it seems you use fresh content i really like it.
keep updating us!
obat herbal diabetes
cara mengatasi keputihan
cara mengobati bisul
cara menghilangkan bintik putih
cara menghilangkan bekas luka
cara menyembuhkan asam urat
cara mengatasi haid tidak teratur
By
Unknown, at 3:55 a.m.
Great Post!Keep Sharing With Us
Business Development Assignment
By
amanda stephanie, at 2:28 a.m.
This article is very useful, thank you for sharing. And allow me to share articles too, it's about health and treatment. God willing
Cara Mengobati Retina Mata Lepas, Robek, Putus Dan Rusak, Cara Menyembuhkan Telinga Bernanah Menahun, Cara Menghilangkan Benjolan Ganglion Di Pergelangan Tangan, Cara Menyembuhkan Erosi Serviks Secara Alami
By
Raya Resmana, at 2:54 a.m.
Very Informative Post!Thanks For Sharing
Digital Marketing Company Amravati
Digital Marketing Amravati
By
ChristineMarie, at 1:24 a.m.
Great Blog!Keep Sharing With Us
College Assignment Help
By
Assignment Help, at 2:30 a.m.
thank you for sharing
makanan untuk menggemukkan badan
By
obat sakit tipes di apotek, at 2:23 a.m.
It was really a great information thanks for sharing.
cara mengatasi kaki bengkak secara alami
cara alami mengatasu biang keringat pada bayi
cara mengobati iritasi mata
By
Lalisa Lisa, at 12:15 a.m.
canada goose
birkin bag
hermes belt
bape clothing
adidas yeezy boost
louboutin shoes
golden goose
nike air vapormax
supreme outlet
coach factory outlet
By
yanmaneee, at 10:35 p.m.
It was really a great information thanks for sharing.
obat infeksi telinga alami
By
Jisoo Blackpink, at 11:51 p.m.
thnk u
https://obatmata.atavist.com/obat-mata-seperti-berpasir-merah-perih-100-herbal-alami-ada-testimoninya
https://obatmata.atavist.com/obat-mata-iritasi-karena-softlens-paling-bagus-100-herbal-alami-aman-ada-testimoninya
By
obat mata juling sebelah, at 12:06 a.m.
The first step in Medicine Essay Writing Services is the choice of topic. The topic that is chosen by the writer determines the quality of the paper.
By
jacklinemelda, at 5:51 a.m.
Politic always is about skill of desception.
and you can find Toto Hk result at: https://unitogel.com/
anda win lottery haha
By
Anonymous, at 3:06 a.m.
Bandar Judi Slot Online
Agen Judi Bola Online
Situs Bandar Judi
By
gustibet, at 4:08 a.m.
Custom Assignment Help online produces different assignments, including Custom Assignment Writing Service, to help students deal with the Legit Essay Writing Servicechallenges they face every day.
By
meldaresearchusa, at 1:29 a.m.
Situs Anda bagus, dan jangan lupa kunjungi balik situs kami
Poker Online Terbaik
togel online
BambuPoker
Bambubet
situs judi online
taruhan bola
bola online
situs judi bola
togel web
judi togel online
togel online terpercaya
bandar togel
judi bola online terpercaya
sbobet casino
poker online
togel online terpercaya
dominoqq
Togel Hari Ini
bocoran togel besok
https://www.initaruhan.online/
By
BambuBet, at 2:37 p.m.
Mau Nyari Vidio Bokep yang Masih aktif dan bisa di bukak?
Klik link di bawah ini , Jangan sampek Colinya tertunda yah bro
Cerita Dewasa
Video Bokep
Foto Bugil
Cerita Cinta
Nonton Bokep
Intip juga beberapa Link Alternatif di bawah ini :
Bokep Online
Video Dewasa
Video Mesum
Bokep Mesum
ABG Seksi
Nyari BO Poker Aman da nterpercaya ? Klik disini
Situs Poker Online
Bandar Bola Terbaik
Atau Chat Customer Service kami di :
BambuPoker
Bambubet
https://www.intipkuy.com/
Terimakasih , Salam Admin Khalessi
By
Khaleesi Sitepu, at 2:45 p.m.
Mau Nyari Vidio Bokep yang Masih aktif dan bisa di bukak?
Klik link di bawah ini , Jangan sampek Colinya tertunda yah bro
Cerita Dewasa
Video Bokep
Foto Bugil
Cerita Cinta
Nonton Bokep
Intip juga beberapa Link Alternatif di bawah ini :
Bokep Online
Video Dewasa
Video Mesum
Bokep Mesum
ABG Seksi
Nyari BO Poker Aman da nterpercaya ? Klik disini
Situs Poker Online
Bandar Bola Terbaik
Atau Chat Customer Service kami di :
BambuPoker
Bambubet
https://www.intipkuy.com/
Terimakasih , Salam Admin Khalessi
By
Khaleesi Sitepu, at 11:23 a.m.
Situs Anda bagus, dan jangan lupa kunjungi balik situs kami
Poker Online Terbaik
togel online
BambuPoker
Bambubet
situs judi online
taruhan bola
bola online
situs judi bola
togel web
judi togel online
togel online terpercaya
bandar togel
judi bola online terpercaya
sbobet casino
poker online
togel online terpercaya
dominoqq
Togel Hari Ini
bocoran togel besok
https://www.initaruhan.online/
By
Situs Promo, at 11:41 a.m.
It is normal for students to be anxious about hiring an online professional Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services Provider because they can never be sure whether they can get high-quality affordable Custom Research Paper Services and the right Research Paper Assistance Services or not.
By
Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services, at 7:02 a.m.
Prediksi Togel Hari Ini
FREETOGEL
Prediksi Togel Hongkong
Prediksi Togel Singapura
Prediksi Togel Sydney
HARIANANGKA
Prediksi Togel Hongkong
Prediksi Togel Singapura
Prediksi Togel Sydney
By
Unknown, at 2:33 p.m.
Spesial Promo Khusus Member Setia Di Situs CrownQQ
Yuk Buruan Daftar Dan Mainkan 9 Game Berkualitas Hanya Di Situs CrownQQ
Agen BandarQ Terbesar Dan Terpercaya Di indonesia
Rasakan Sensasi serunya bermain di CrownQQ, Agen BandarQ Yang 100% Gampang Menang
Games Yang di Hadirkan CrownQQ :
* Poker Online
* BandarQ
* Domino99
* Bandar Sakong
* Sakong
* Bandar66
* AduQ
* Sakong
* Perang Baccarat (New Game)
Promo Yang Hadir Di CrownQQ Saat ini Adalah :
=> Bonus Refferal 20%
=> Bonus Turn Over 0,5%
=> Minimal Depo 20.000
=> Minimal WD 20.000
=> 100% Member Asli
=> Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
=> Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
=> Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android
=> Di Layani Dengan 5 Bank Terbaik
<< Contact_us >>
WHATSAPP : +855882357563
LINE : CS CROWNQQ
TELEGRAM : +855882357563
Link Resmi CrownQQ:
RATUAJAIB. COM
RATUAJAIB.NET
RATUAJAIB.INFO
DEPOSIT VIA PULSA TELKOMSEL | XL 24 JAM NONSTOP
CROWNQQ | AGEN BANDARQ | ADUQ ONLINE | DOMINOQQ TERBAIK | DOMINO99 ONLINE TERBESAR
By
marsyaoktavia02@gmail.com, at 2:18 a.m.
Looking for Advanced Digital Marketing Course in Vadodara ? Join Digital Products. Learn from experienced trainers, Live Project Training, 10+ Digital Marketing Modules with 100% placement.
By
Digital Sheetal Sharma, at 4:33 a.m.
Online Kids Track Suit India: Age: 2 To 14 Years Buy from the new collection of tracksuits for kids in a variety of colours at low offer price & discounts at COD, Easy Returns & Exchanges. Order Now.
By
Mayank Sharma, at 6:19 a.m.
Your blog is great!!! Good content!! I would recommend this to my friends. But are you looking for online casino site? Click the link below:
온라인카지노사이트
안전놀이터
By
oncasinosite, at 1:58 a.m.
Hello there! Nice article!!! But anyways here’s one of the trusted online baccarat site we can offer you so many promo and event everyday!! Good luck!!!
토토
안전토토사이트
스포츠토토
By
betmantoto, at 1:59 a.m.
Thank you for sharing your truth! I have so much more that I would like to say but I don't think its necessary. Just visit my site:
사설토토
카지노사이트
파워볼
By
sportstoto, at 2:00 a.m.
SEO Services Mumbai- Crawl My Line is a leading SEO Agency offering the best SEO services in Mumbai which helps you to get more traffic on the website.
By
Nitin Singh, at 10:19 a.m.
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea. 바카라사이트
By
바카라사이트, at 4:30 a.m.
Simply unadulterated brilliance from you here. I have never expected something not as much as this from you and 먹튀검증 have not confounded me by any reach out of the inventive vitality. I acknowledge you will keep the quality work going on.
By
토토사이트, at 11:30 p.m.
I am overwhelmed by your post with such a nice topic. Usually I visit your 안전놀이터 and get updated through the information you include but today’s blog would be the most appreciable. Well done! Your information was very useful to me. That's exactly what I've been looking for 메이저토토사이트! What kind of article do you like?? If someone asks, they will say that they like the article related to 메이저사이트 just like your article. If you are interested in my writing, please visit !! What a nice comment!Nice to meet you. I live in a different country from you. Your writing will be of great help to me and to many other people living in our country. I was looking for a post like this, but I finally found 토토사이트.
By
토토사이트, at 11:33 p.m.
It is very difficult to meet someone who suits my taste. I haven't met a lot, but I am very happy to find someone who writes an article that suits my taste. Collecting these kinds of articles is my hobby, but once you come to my site, 주식디비 and enjoy, I would appreciate it.
By
Anonymous, at 11:35 p.m.
Post a Comment
<< Home